Mine Safety and Health Administration
National Mine Safety and Health Academy
Heat Stress in Mining
The information contained in this page was extracted from MSHA Safety Manual Number 6. For the purpose of providing you with a document better suited for presentation on the internet we have excluded some of the graphics found in the manual.
Historically, the engineer has made mining possible for human beings. Today the proper object is to provide conditions in which the miner is a contented individual operating at maximum efficiency.
P.R. Davis and A. A. Knight
Ergonomics of Mining, Medicine in the Mining Industries
J. M. Rogan, ed., F. A. Davis Company, 1972
This is a revised version of a manual originally published under the same title in 1976. Since then, no new heat stress studies have been made in mining.
A list of references (Bibliography) is also included for those interested in additional information on the topics discussed in this pamphlet.
There is the right of every red-blooded man to be assured that his work will be a daily satisfaction to himself; that it is a work which is contributing to the welfare and advance of his country; and that it will build for him a position of dignity and consequence among his fellows.
Herbert C. Hoover,
Principles of Mining ,
McGraw-Hill Book Co., Inc. 1909
Enforcement is a good principle which can only be effective when accompanied with a good education and training effort, an effort to educate the miners in the health hazards, an effort to train miners on the importance of maintaining a healthy environment, an effort to motivate the miners to know and play a major role to improve the environment in mines.
Robert E. Barrett, Administrator,
Mining Enforcement and Safety Administration,
Annual Meeting of the American Public Health
Deep mines and mines sunk in hot countries are hot work sites. Some underground mines in moderate geographic zones are hot because of the unusually high heat flow from the earth. Many mines in the southwestern United States are located along a high heat zone. The thrust for the development of new sources of minerals calls for an expansion of underground mining in deeper, and therefore, hotter levels of the earth crust.
In mining, as in other industries, the exposure of workers to very hot conditions is unhealthy and unproductive. Persons working in hot, humid work sites tend to be inefficient; quite often workers prefer to stay away from work or ignore unsafe working situations. Studies in South African gold mines have shown that high temperatures reduce the work output of miners.
Dexterity and coordination, ability to observe irregular, faint optical signs, ability to remain alert during lengthy and monotonous tasks, and the ability to make quick decisions are adversely affected by the heat strain. For example, in a 3hour drilling operation performed under varying room temperatures, the best results were obtained at 84° F; the performance was reduced to 75 percent capacity at a room temperature of 91° F, to 50 percent at 96, and to 25 percent at 99° F. For a new employee., 77° F room temperature is the upper limit for best performance. Heat strain can also show itself in the form of irritation, anger, and other emotions leading to rash acts by persons performing hazardous jobs. The lowest accident rates have been related to men working at temperatures below 70° F, the highest to temperatures of 80° F and over.
There is some evidence that older persons have a lower tolerance for heat. They start to sweat later than do younger individuals. It takes longer for body temperature to return to normal levels in older individuals exposed to heat stress. In one study the majority of all the individuals who fell victim to heatstroke were over 60 years of age.
The body metabolism provides heat and energy for our physiological functions.
When the environment is cooler than our body, part of the excess body beat is lost to the environment through convection and radiation. An active person loses part of his body heat through evaporation. However, in a hot environment the body gains heat from the environment through convection and radiation.
The body core can dissipate its heat only through the shell. Blood serves as a vehicle for heat transfer.
Warm-blooded animals can function regularly in almost all types of weather and climate because they can maintain their body temperature within a narrow range. Carbohydrates, fats and proteins in our food provide energy for our daily activities. The human body, like mechanical devices and machines, is not 100 percent efficient. At best, only 25 percent of the energy generated by the body's metabolism is converted into mechanical work. Thus, at least 75 percent of the energy produced by metabolism is converted into heat which is needed to support the metabolic process. However, too much heat will interfere with the metabolism and cause health problems such as heatstroke, fainting, exhaustion, cramps and water deficiency.
The human body may be thought of as having a core and a shell; this assumption will make it easier to understand the heat control in the body. The core contains the deep muscles and tissues, including the heart, lungs, abdominal organs, and brain. The shell contains the skin, tissues forming the skin base, and the muscles close to the skin; the hands and feet are also part of the body shell.
Rectal temperatures are a measure of the core temperature. At rest, the body core temperature remains almost uniform. Under extreme conditions-from sleeping in a cold environment to doing hard work in a hot work site -- the core temperature varies from 95 to 104°F.
The health of a person at work and at rest depends upon the stability of the core body temperature. The core cannot store an excessive amount of heat without upsetting its delicate temperature balance. oral temperatures are a measure of core and the shell temperatures; the body core can dissipate its heat only through the shell. Blood serves as an effective vehicle for heat transfer between the body core and the shell.
|The human body at rest will dissipate the heat generated by metabolic process. Evaporation, convection and radiation are the methods of body heat dissipation.|
Two or more bodies having different temperatures can exchange their heat in several ways:
- convection is a mechanism of heat exchange
through a medium such as air or water
- conduction is the transfer of heat between
two bodies in contact
- radiation is a heat loss due to the emission of heat rays from hotter to cooler surfaces
Muscular work can increase the heat production in the body 10 to 20 times that at rest. The excess heat generated in the body is dissipated through convection, radiation and evaporation. When the body is at rest, the combination of convection and radiation accounts for about threefourths of the dissipated body heat; and the remaining one-fourth is lost through evaporation. Heat loss through evaporation can take place in the following ways:
- sweat evaporation through almost two million sweat glands in the skin
- saturation of the inhaled air in the lungs with
- invisible loss of water through the skin without involvement of the sweat glands
The human body, when exposed to a wide range of increasing heat loads, can mobilize its resources and restore a balance between heat gain and heat loss. This leads to a new steady core temperature at a somewhat higher level. Heat stress refers to the total heat-related load on the individual from both environmental and metabolic sources.
An increasing environmental heat stress causes changes in sweat rate, heartbeat rate, and body core temperature of the affected individual.
Heat strain refers to the adjustments made by the individual in response to the heat stress. These adjustments include biochemical, physiological, and psychological processes.
Healthy and physically fit persons are able to work under heat strain as long as sweat evaporation takes place; by contrast, persons with health problems have a limited capacity for heat strain endurance.
An increase in the sweat rate is the first sign of the heat strain. The steady rise of the sweat rate causes an excessive wetting of the skin. Extended exposure to heat will cause a decline in sweat rate. The sweat gland fatigue and consequent reduction in sweat production indicates a very high level of heat strain.
Some people have no sweat glands at all; such a condition should disqualify them from working in hot environments.
Individuals working in hot areas under emergency conditions (mine rescue workers) and highly motivated individuals working in nonemergency conditions may overstrain themselves. To prevent this kind of strain, the workloads may be reduced, more recovery time may be allowed, or cool rest areas may be provided.
High or moderately high levels of work produce a great deal of heat in the body. Moreover, the following factors add to the discomfort of a hot work site:
- high air temperatures
- high surface temperatures
- high atmospheric humidity
- relatively low air movement
- Hot work site means any combination of air
temperature, humidity, radiation and. wind speed that exceeds a wet bulb globe temperature of 79° F.
The wet bulb globe temperature is measured with the help of a cluster of thermometers adapted to measure various work .site temperatures:
- dry bulb thermometer is used to measure the temperature of mine air to get an
estimate of convective heat exchange in the mine work area
- wet-bulb thermometer reading and its comparison with the dry-bulb thermometer reading is
used as an estimate of evaporative heat exchange
- globe-thermometer reading
indicates the radiative heat coming from the surfaces around the work site
- the temperatures indicated by three thermometers are used in a formula which produces the wet bulb globe temperature (WBGT). If the WBGT exceeds 79°F, the work site is "hot" according to the above definition
Proper Work Practices
Generally speaking, work site temperatures; humidity, and air movement can be controlled to lower the heat load and to provide tolerable working conditions in hot mines. At a point, however, these control measures fail to prevent the temperature rise in a worker's body core and proper work practices may be the only heat-stress control measure. The objective of a good work practice in a hot work site is to prevent the body core temperature from rising above 100° F (38°C). The excessive heat gain must be offset by adequate periods of heat loss. Desirable work practices include the following:
- increasing workers' heat tolerance by a heat acclimatization, and by increasing their physical fitness
- a work-rest regimen--frequent breaks and reasonably short work periods
- pacing a task
- performing heavy tasks in cooler areas or at cooler times
- rotating personnel on hot jobs providing readily accessible cooler rest areas, cool--50 degrees to 60 degrees F (10 degrees to 15 degrees C)--drinking water, and encouraging all workers to drink a cup of water every 15 to 20 minutes
- for persons not on a restricted salt diet by physician's orders, a heavier use of salt at meals and drinking slightly salted water (about one level tablespoon salt to fifteen quarts of water)
Repeated exposure to heat stress may increase the body's tolerance to heat. Acclimatization is a long-term adjustment of an individual to a stress. An acclimatized person can perform many tasks in a hot and humid work site where a non-acclimatized person cannot work.
A person should be given enough time for adjustment to a hot work site where the wet bulb globe temperature (WBGT) exceeds 79°F. A recommended six-day acclimatization schedule calls for the miner to work in the hot work site for 60 percent of the time on the first work day, and an additional 10 percent of the time on the days that follow the first day:
|50 percent exposure|
60 percent exposure
70 percent exposure
80 percent exposure
90 percent exposure
100 percent exposure
|50 percent exposure|
60 percent exposure
90 percent exposure
100 percent exposure
|Miners working in hot areas should know about the hazards of heat stress!|
A mine supervisor who is knowledgeable about the symptoms of heat disorders can recognize heat stress areas and take corrective action for workers who display heat-related symptoms. Underground miners tend to work in a self-paced manner due to the nature of mining; even' so, supervisors with an understanding of heat stress should look out for miners who may be straining themselves.
A person subject to heat stress may not be able to recognize the strain symptoms. This is why all miners working in hot areas should know the following:
- what are the signs of imminent heat illness
- how to administer first aid to heat stress victims
- how to reduce the heat stress
|Medical surveillance is recommended for miners who work in hot work sites.|
Medical surveillance can be set up for miners who may be working in hot work sites. This will require medical examination by a physician for all personnel who are to be assigned to hot jobs for the first time. The physician will examine the condition of the heart, blood vessels, kidneys, liver, glands of internal secretion, respiratory system, and the skin.
The incidence of heat stroke, heat exhaustion, and heat cramps should be reported. Such reports will be useful for future heat stress studies.
Mine planning, ventilation and air conditioning may reduce the heat stress to acceptable levels. Proper mine planning will provide for conveniently available cool rest areas and allow the worker to take the needed rest where he can cool off. When natural cooler air is not available, air conditioning becomes necessary.
Ventilation and air conditioning may reduce the heat stress in hot work sites.|
The solar head load can be reduced by the use of a canopy.
The sources of heat in surface mines and mills include the sun, machines, dryers, and the kilns. The solar heat load can be reduced by the use of a canopy in most cases. The radiant heat from dryers and kilns can be controlled by shielding. The heat gain by the operator's body is partially lost through evaporation; therefore dry air moving past the body can be helpful.
Wall-rock heat is the major source of heat in many underground mines. Ventilation is the best method of lessening the effect of wall-rock heat on miners. Sometimes air cooling or conditioning is necessary.
All powered equipment-diesel engines, electric motors, compressed air equipment-contributes to the heat load of an underground mine. Generally, most lighting systems convert energy to heat. Excess heat can be reduced by using more efficient equipment and providing efficient ventilation in the mine.
Ground water flowing through hot rock formations becomes hot. The transfer of heat from the ground water to the underground mine air can be controlled by using covered ditches or insulated piping for a speedy transfer of hot waters to the surface.
From 50 to 100 percent of the energy set free in blasting shows up in the form of heat. Efficient blasting procedures will reduce the unwanted release of heat into the mine air.
A part of the miner's body metabolic energy is released to the mine air. In a crowded work site metabolic heat can be a problem. Automation and remote control of mining will serve as a control measure where metabolic heat is a problem.
|All miners working in hot areas should know how to administer first aid to a heat stress victim.|
- hot dry skin of red, spotted, or bluish or purplish coloration
- rising, high body temperature
- brain disorders -- mental confusion, delirium, fainting, convulsions, and coma
Heat stroke results from the failure of the heat regulatory system in the body. The failure of sweating leads to the loss of evaporative cooling of the skin and an uncontrolled rapid rising of the body temperature. In milder cases of heat disorders, sweating may still be evident in spite of high body temperature.
Heat fainting happens when the brain suffers from a temporary shortage of blood supply.
Heat cramps may be the result of slat deficiency in the body.
Heat fainting is the most common form of heat disability. It happens when the individual is in a standing position, the return of venous blood to the heart is not sufficient and the brain suffers from a temporary shortage of blood supply. The victim's. prostration helps to restore the normal blood circulation. The victim should be removed to a cooler area. A prompt and complete recovery usually follows the prostration.
The signs of heat exhaustion include weakness, lowered blood pressure, signs of fainting, tiredness, nausea and headache, even between work activities. Clammy and moist skin and a pale, muddy, or flushed look are also present. If sitting, the victim may faint on getting up. Heat cramps are painful contractions of skeletal muscles in arms, legs, or the abdominal area of the body.
Heat exhaustion and heat cramps are the results of salt deficiency in- the body. The loss of salt through sweating and the urine may exceed the salt intake. Drinking large volumes of water without replacing the lost salt will allow the water to enter the muscles and cause spasms. Workers not on a restricted salt diet by physician's orders should use more salt at meal time to make up for the loss of salt. Salt tablets irritate the stomach and should not be used. Painful spasms of muscles can be promptly relieved by intravenous infusion of salted liquid. In cases of high salt deficiency, restoration of body salt balance takes several days.
|In hot work sites, cool drinking water containing 0.1 percent salt should be used.|
Some individuals feel that by restricting their water intake in hot jobs they reduce the amount of sweat dripping from their faces and into their eyes. They should be convinced that they are trading safety for comfort and that a voluntary restriction of their water intake may lead to water?deficiency heat exhaustion and even heat stroke. The risk of dehydration is greater if the major part of the daily meals is dry or dehydrated. The victim of water deficiency and heat exhaustion is thirsty. In mild cases, rest in a cool area and the taking of water results in a speedy recovery.
Prickly heat or heat rash is in the form of tiny red blisters in the affected skin area. Affected areas of the skin are treated with mild drying lotions; cooled sleeping quarters allow for the drying of the skin between heat exposures. Prickly heat is related to the wasting away (maceration) of the skin by the continuous presence of unevaporated sweat.
Certain areas of the earth's crust release more heat than others; mines located along high heat zones are normally hot. This map shows the zones of high heat in the Western United States.
Some deep mining operations, located along high heat zones in western United States, represent hot work sites. Workers performing hazardous jobs and exposed to temperatures in excess of 80° F are known to have high accident rates. Intensive physical activity in hot work sites results in high sweat and heartbeat rates. Long-term exposure of non-acclimatized persons to heat stress is unhealthy and unproductive. Selection, acclimatization, and education of employees for working in hot work sites, coupled with an effective engineering control of heat at the work site, will provide a healthy work environment in mines and mills.
2. Brouha, L. Physiology in Industry. Second Edition, Pergamon Press, New York, 1967.
3. Leithead, C.S. , and A.R. Lind. Heat Stress and Heat Disorders. Akademiai Kiado, Budapest, Distrib. In U.S. by Intercontinental Medical Book Corp., New York, 1969.
4. Misaqi, F.L., J.G. Inderberg, P.D. Blumenstem, and Ted Naiman. Heat Stress in Hot U. S. Mines and Criteria for Standards for Mining in Hot Environments. MESA IR 1048, 1976.
5. Rogan, J.M.. (ed.). Medicine in the Mining Industries. F. A. Davis Co., Philadelphia, 1972.
6. U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare,
NIOSH. Criteria for Recommended Standards . . . Occupational Exposure to Hot Environments. Revised Criteria. Publication No. HSM 86?113, 1986.
7. World Health Organization (WHO). Health Factors Involved in Working Under Conditions of Heat Stress. WHO Technical Report Series, No. 412, Geneva, 1969.
Carbohydrates - Organic compounds, such as sugar, starches, celluloses, which form the supporting tissues of plants and are important food for animals.
Dehydration - Loss of water or body fluids.
Metabolism - Chemical changes in living cells by which energy is provided for vital processes and activities and new material assimilated to repair the waste.
Wall Rock - The country rock immediately adjoining mineral deposits.