MSHA - Directorate of Technical Support A Troubleshooting Guide for
Roof Support Systems


Appendix C

C.1 BENT BOLT

A bolt that has a bend in it may require more torque during mixing than a straight bolt. If the bolt scrapes the sides of the borehole wall during mixing, the increased torque required to mix the grout can exceed the breaking torque of the tension nut, which will result in thread take-up during mixing. Observe the operator as the bolts are straightened and check the bolts for straightness, then insert the bolts in the boreholes by hand without resin. If there is excessive drag, then the bolts have not been straightened enough. In some instances e.g., large bar diameters or higher grade material, the bolts cannot be straightened enough to prevent thread take-up during mixing. The only alternative in this case would be to use a torque inhibitor with a breaking torque that is high enough to prevent premature thread take-up.

C.2 TORQUE INHIBITOR TOO STRONG/WEAK

A torque inhibitor that is too strong can prevent a support from being properly tensioned since excessive torque must be applied to the bolt to break the torque inhibitor. When the torque inhibitor is too weak, thread take-up occurs prematurely resulting in a very low or a non-tensioned bolt. To check if the torque inhibitor is functioning properly, drill a hole that is 4 or 5" shorter than the bolt length. Next, install and rotate the bolt to mix the grout as per the manufacturers recommendations. After the grout is mixed examine the tension nut. The torque inhibitor should still be intact. If the torque inhibitor has broken it is too weak. If it is still intact take a torque wrench and turn the nut until the torque inhibitor breaks. This torque value is the break-away torque and should not exceed 70 % of the installed torque. If after conducting several of these checks the break-away torque is too high or too low the torque inhibitor is not functioning properly and the tension nuts should be replaced.

C.3 RESIDUAL TORQUE-TORQUE INHIBITOR

There should not be a significant residual torque after the torque inhibitor breaks. To check if the torque inhibitor is interfering with the thread take-up during tensioning, first hold the end of the bolt in a vise or with a pipe wrench. Next, turn the tension nut until the torque inhibitor breaks. When checking a coupler hold the coupler and turn the mechanical bolt into it. If after a few rotations the torque inhibitor has not broken away and the nut/coupler cannot be turned by hand, the torque inhibitor is not functioning properly. Repeat this procedure with several nuts/couplers and if the problem is consistent the tension nuts/couplers should be replaced. Some tension nuts/couplers might have a low residual torque after the torque inhibitor breaks. This residual torque should be insignificant in proportion to the installed torque and should be consistent with each nut/coupler.

C.4 THREAD BINDING

Thread binding can interfere with thread take-up during tensioning resulting in improperly tensioned bolts. To check for thread binding first knock out the torque inhibitor, then thread the nut/coupler onto the bolt. The nut/coupler should thread easily down the entire length of the bolt threads. If the nut/coupler locks up or excessive resistance is felt, visually inspect the bolt threads for flat threads or burrs. Check several bolts with different nuts/couplers to determine if the problem is with the bolt or nut/coupler threads.

If after checking the threads as described above there is no evidence of binding and the tension nuts/couplers have shear pins the problem might be a soft shear pin and bolts with sharp ends. Certain types of nuts/couplers have the shear pins in the threads instead of below the threads. If the shear pin is aluminum or soft steel and the ends of the bolts have sharp edges, the bolt will sometimes cut through the pin instead of shearing it cleanly. As the bolt cuts the pin the metal shards that are produced can block the threads and cause the nut/coupler to bind up. If the bolts have sharp edges and you suspect that this might be causing the binding, install a bolt out of pattern, then take the nut/coupler off. Inspect the nut/coupler looking for metal shards lodged in the threads. Also check the position of the shear pin. The pin should have sheared and not be wedged in the threads.

C.5 LIMITED THREAD ENGAGEMENT

Check the thread engagement by threading the nut/coupler onto the bolt until the end of the bolt is flush with the nut/coupler. Place a mark on the bolt indicating the full engagement of the nut/coupler. Then measure the distance from this mark to the end of the bolt. Nuts should have a tapped length at least equal to 1 times the nominal bolt diameter with which they are to be used. Couplers should have a tapped length at least equal to 2 times the nominal bolt diameter.

C.6 POOR STRATA - ANCHORAGE EXCEEDED

To determine the maximum anchorage available a pull test must be conducted. If it is determined that the anchorage available is not sufficient for the particular application, then try a stronger grout, a longer grouted length, or fully grouting the bolts. If it is determined that the problem is due to poor strata conditions in the anchorage zone try longer bolts. If that does not work or it is not feasible then the next step would be to try a different support system.

C.7 VISCOUS GROUT

If the grout is too thick then the torque required to mix it might exceed the breaking torque of the tension nut shear mechanism. The remedy would be to either get a less viscous resin or nuts with a stronger shear mechanism.

C.8 PREMATURE TIGHTENING

Premature tightening by the operator can result in improperly installed supports. It is critical that the operator waits long enough for the grout to cure before tightening the bolts. To check for premature tightening you must observe the operator during installation. If the operator is not waiting for the length of time recommended by the grout manufacturer before tightening, then instruct the operator in the correct installation procedure.

C.9 PLATE HELD TOO FAR FROM ROOF

If the operator does not hold the plate close enough to the roof there will not be enough threads left to tighten the bolt, which could result in a non-tensioned installation. As a check, observe the operator during installation. If the operator is not holding the plate the correct distance from the roof as recommended by the manufacturer, then instruct the operator in the correct installation procedure.

C.10 PLATE GALLING

To check for galling have the bolter install some bolts out of pattern, then remove the nuts so that a visual inspection of the nuts and plates can be made. If galling is evident only in some instances, this could indicate poor installation procedure. If galling occurred for each installation check for burrs around the plate or rough spots on the nuts. Galling can also be caused by a plate/washer mismatch (see A.18 ).

C.11 PLATE - NUT MISMATCH

If the nut flange is too large and does not conform to the plate embossment the nut will not seat completely on the plate and excessive galling could result.

C.12 GROUT TOO SHORT

The only way to determine if the grouted length is too short is to conduct a pull test. In certain situations e.g., varying roof strata conditions, a grout length that performed well in the past can become inadequate. By conducting pull tests in areas where you suspect that the roof conditions have changed you will be able to decide if the grout length should be increased.

WASHER BADLY DEFORMED

See Mechanical Bolt Section (include link)

WASHER CRACKS

See Mechanical Bolt Section (include link)